Best Pizza in New Brighton

Q: What are you known for?

We are known for Vegetarian Food, Meat Lovers Pizza, Veggie Pizza, Deep Dish Pizza, Chicken Parmesan, Vegan Food, Breadsticks, Gluten Free Food, Salads, White Pizza, Sicilian Pizza, Hand Tossed Pizza, Buffalo Chicken Pizza, BBQ Chicken Pizza, Grilled Chicken, Grilled Chicken Salad, Chicken Salad, Dessert, BBQ, Calzone, Stromboli, Cauliflower Crust Pizza, Cheesy Breadsticks, Deep Dish, Chili, Meatballs, Antipasto Salad, Garlic Knots, and Gluten Free

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in **New Brighton, PA** at **400 9th St Suite D**

Fresh Pizza, Bold Flavors, Made Right Every Single Day

Order online

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Al's Pizza

Have you ever enjoyed American pizzeria classics made with real passion? This spot brings together rounds, deep dish, Sicilian squares, calzones, subs and crowd-favorite appetizers, all prepared with care every day. From cheesy slices to hearty bowls, every item reflects the shop’s long commitment to serving dependable food with warm service and an easy ordering experience.

Hey, Al's Pizza has a Food Trailer!

Explore Real American Pizzeria Flavor

The menu highlights round pizza, deep dish, Sicilian trays, calzones, subs, appetizers and specialty creations loaded with bold sauces and fresh toppings. Have you ever tried a cheesy slice built on dough made daily? From pepperoni rolls to hearty bowls, each item reflects the shop’s commitment to quality and consistency, giving guests dependable American comfort food.

Explore Our Menu

Simple Ordering for Busy Days

Ordering online lets you enjoy American pizzeria favorites without the wait. Whether you want a round pie, Sicilian squares, calzones or subs, everything is available with quick pickup options. Have you ever ordered a pizza and had it ready right on time? That convenience is part of the service. The digital menu is clear, fast and designed for easy reordering.

Order Now

A Closer Look at Your Favorites

The gallery showcases golden-brown Sicilian slices, cheese-loaded rounds, perfectly baked calzones and subs layered with fresh ingredients.

Casual Pickup with Space to Relax

While primarily a takeout spot, guests often pause outside or relax nearby while waiting for their food. The experience is built around fast service and freshly made American pizzeria classics. Have you ever waited for a hot Sicilian cut straight from the oven? That moment of anticipation adds to the charm of stopping by for your favorites.

Stop By for Fresh American Pizza

📍 Location: 400 9th St ⏰ Hours: Convenient daily hours for easy pickup Guests visit for dependable service and classics like round pies, Sicilian squares, calzones, and subs. The shop keeps things simple: good food, friendly staff, and consistent quality. Have you ever picked up a pie and enjoyed it before reaching home? That’s the kind of everyday experience offered here, with smooth pickup and reliable service.

What our guests are saying

I got the deep dish it was great. My buddy got the angry gyro pizza we swapped each other a slice... both were delicious. You dont find deep dish too often in this area.

We T.

We always get the deep dish with pepperoni, and it’s my favorite pizza ever. Mind blowing. (We drizzle a little hot honey on top and it’s insane.) The amount of cheese you get is out of this world, definitely makes it worth the price in my eyes. Best pizza joint in Beaver County for sure. I also really love the pickle pizza!!

Evan T.

I grew up eating police station pizza, D&G, and breezy pizza on a regular basis. I’m sorry fans of the other places but Al,s is def the best pie in the county.